We earn from sales through Amazon affiliate links on this page. Read the Full Disclaimer here
The insoles in your shoes might be the most important feature that awards comfort to your feet. Some shoes feel normal and plain so you probably don’t understand what comfortable shoes mean.
There is a level of comfort that you only feel because you have been uncomfortable for a while. Then there is a level of comfort that makes you feel like you’ve never worn shoes.
The Sperry brand doesn’t make replacement insoles for their shoes so you might have to get new insoles from a different source.
There have been reviews about the lack of support in the Sperry shoes. You may not have to wait for your Sperry insoles to get ruined before getting something better. Speaking of something better, we are going for the best.
Top Picks
- Most Durable: Spenco Polysorb Heavy-duty Insoles
- Best Thin Insoles: Dr. Feet Adjustable Inserts
- Best Space-filler Insoles: Walkomfy Orthotic Insoles
- Best Comfortable Insoles: Powerstep Pinnacle Maxx Insoles
12 Best Replacement Insoles For Sperry Shoes
Pedag Terry Cotton Insoles
The Pedag Terry Cotton insole is rated over 4 stars on Amazon with over a thousand contributions.
That is proof enough of what to expect. These insoles will not only fit perfectly in your Sperry shoes but will offer the comfort you may not expect from your Sperry shoes.
These Insoles absorb sweat to avoid that wet discomfort after a long day’s work. It also features odor control.
Ordinary Sperry shoes won’t get you all these. Just so you know, this pair of insoles were made for boat shoes so you have nothing to worry about.
The sweetest part is these insoles can be washed. Below are some comments that mention Pedag Terry Cotton Insoles;
I pulled the insoles in my Sperry shoes out and I have replaced them with Terry Cotton Insoles I found on Amazon.
My wife was going to throw the shoes out before I started using the Terry insoles. Also, they are washing-machine-safe. I have only washed them twice though, but they have held up well and they are far more comfortable.
These are perfect for summer, whether in socks or not. They are machine washable. You can trim them for a perfect fit.
The thin and cushy rubber at the back makes shoes and sandals more comfortable. They are antiskid…. But I’m giving it four stars.
The black ones aren’t as soft as the white ones. Also, there is only one width available. I would love it wider.
Pros:
- Soft-cushioning
- Affordable
- Antiskid
- Washable with machine
- Odor control
- Comfortable
- Better replacement for Sperry insoles
Cons:
- No wider sizes
- Not durable
- Thin texture
Superfeet Orthotic Shoe Inserts
This is one of the best insoles you can ever go for when you desire arch support; a feature that is lacking in Sperry shoes.
This is beyond a perfect replacement. Rather, this is what Sperry shoes should try to give us. We need to understand the benefit of supportive insoles.
Sperry insoles are truly comfortable but, without support, that comfort depletes slowly. These insoles are not just better at providing comfort but there is enough support to keep you on your feet for so long.
Virtually every review has to mention the level of support offered by these insoles. Below are some comments that mention Superfeet Orthotic Shoe Inserts;
Wow! This works far better than any other insole I have ever tried. I work in the surgery department and have to stay on my feet for about twelve hours per day.
I can boast of trying virtually all styles of shoe inserts, hoping some squishy comfort will cure the ache in my feet.
Within a week of trying these, my feet don’t hurt anymore. Instead of going for comfort, I should have gone for better support which these provide.
These insoles provide as much support as you will get from more expensive types… but it started to squeak after a month.
It’s not very bad and it gets less loud after a while but it’s sometimes annoying. The arch support is perfect, anyway. If you want a cushion, these insoles don’t have that… But it’s great if you want to conserve space in your shoes.
Pros:
- Extremely supportive
- Relieves plantar fasciitis
- Conserves space
- Durable
- Better replacement for Sperry Insoles
Cons:
- Expensive
- Not the most comfortable
- Low cushioning
Work-Home Relief Shoe Inserts
This may turn out to be the best pair of insoles on this list. They were built mainly to ease Plantar Fasciitis so perfect arch support is assured.
Asides from the purpose they are built for, these insoles are rated over four stars on Amazon with over 60000 contributions. Below are the top reviews that mention Work-Home Relief Shoe Inserts;
I’m not used to writing reviews on products but this feels necessary. If this review will help in convincing someone in healthcare to purchase this, then I believe I’ve done a good deed. I am a nurse.
I had horrible aches in my feet, my knees, and my back. I bought all kinds of recommended shoes that I could afford, hoping for a miracle, but none of them worked.
I got these shoe inserts and they changed my life. I honestly didn’t feel a difference on the first day but, soon, I noticed how it corrected my posture and my pains were relieved. I have had them for 3 months now and I’m not letting them go.
I had plantar fasciitis and needed shoes with enough support. I had bought a different insole and the fit was off.
These insoles fit perfectly. They are thick and very supportive. There’s not much cushioning, though. I can stand for an extended period, thanks to these inserts.
There’s a limit to that but you won’t expect the same support from other insoles. I recommend this.
Pros:
- Very supportive
- Eases Plantar Fasciitis
- Corrects posture
- Comfortable
- Durability
- Sturdy
- Wide fit
- Better replacement for Sperry Insoles
Cons:
- Low cushioning
- Slightly expensive
Dr. Scholl Work Insoles
Insoles probably carry a part of our body weights and that explains why some insoles do not last. This is only a theory, however, most insoles are not built to last long.
The Dr. Scholl Work Insoles don’t only replace the insoles in your Sperry shoes but they provide beautiful features you can ever hope to get.
They also last longer than many other insoles, in addition to the shock absorption feature. There’s no wonder they are rated over 4 stars on Amazon with over 60000 contributions.
Below are the top reviews that mention Dr. Scholl’s Work Insoles;
I have to be on my feet for at least 8 hours, virtually every day at work. I was in pain before I got these insoles. It was quite hard to walk.
These Insoles worked, almost as soon as I tried them on. It’s been almost a year and they are still intact; as comfortable as ever. There is no doubt I’m buying more of these insoles.
These insoles are comfortable. They will definitely work for plantar fasciitis. The heels are quite cushioned but the rest of the feet are not so.
I won’t be giving five stars because the support seems focused on the heels alone. It is quite alright but I feel pain at the ball of my feet and these won’t help.
Also, I’m not sure if they can keep you on your feet for more than eight hours in a day. Asides from all that, the Dr. Scholl insoles are great.
Pros:
- Durable
- Supportive
- Comfortable
- Relieves Plantar fasciitis
- Cushioned heels
- Shock absorption
- Perfect replacement for Sperry Insoles
Cons:
- Fairly expensive
- Less cushioning under the feet except the heels
Powerstep Pinnacle Insoles
This is a unis*x pair of Insoles. Just like the Work-Home Relief Insoles, they were built to relieve Plantar fasciitis.
They provide the needed support to ease foot pain and work stress. This is one of the most often recommended shoe inserts by medical practitioners.
Asides from the great job they perform, they are not so expensive. Below are the top reviews that mention Powerstep Pinnacle insoles;
For some years, I’ve had plantar fasciitis issues in my left foot. The pain comes and goes away but, a few months ago, it worsened so I went to my doctor. He suggested this brand and this type of insole.
I had expected them to be expensive. He was a hundred percent right. These are comfortable but it may take a while to get used to new hard insoles.
I like the nice color. They are also durable. After so many months, they still look new.
My podiatrist suggested I got this so I ordered a pair and another pair of insoles from a different brand. I just wanted to compare but a second pair is okay, anyway.
The Powerstep insoles worked a lot better. They provide better arch support, and they don’t move around. The insoles are thick so they take up space.
You can use this for oversized shoes, but they worked well for me in my fitted shoes. I’ll buy another one.
Pros:
- Comfortable
- Better arch support
- Relieves Plantar fasciitis
- Medically recommended
- Better replacement for Sperry Insoles
- Thick
Cons:
- Fairly expensive
- Not so soft
- Takes up space
Walkomfy Orthotic Insoles
Walkomfy is as comfortable as the name sounds. These are the inserts better for the boots you wear at work.
These work for Plantar fasciitis, and arch support, and they absorb shock. Below are top reviews that mention Walkomfy Orthotic Insoles;
These are better than the ones my doctor recommended. They provide more arch support and hold up much longer than expensive ones.
These get rid of all my leg pains quickly. I am usually on my feet for about 8 hours a day. When I finally have to sit down, my legs hurt as hell. I put these in my tennis shoes and boom! The pains are all gone.
They take up space so they don’t fit in my dress shoes but these are perfect. I should be doing more shopping with Walkomfy for more healing footwear.
Pros:
- Comfortable
- Durable
- Relieves Plantar fasciitis
- Arch support
- Shock absorption
- Better replacement for Sperry Insoles
- Thick
- Nicely cushioned
Cons:
- Takes up space
- Fairly expensive
Samurai Ninja Relief Insoles
This is another pair of insoles designed against plantar fasciitis. You can see the sword-shaped edges like a true ninja sword.
The insoles stick to the insides of your shoes so they don’t move around when you walk. Below are the top reviews that mention Samurai Ninja Relief Insoles;
For the first time in my life, I had horrible pain in my heels. I have used orthotics in the past for Plantar fasciitis, but most of them seem too high at the arch area, and it feels like I have a tennis ball in there.
These insoles ended the pain. They are very comfortable. I recommend these if you have foot pain.
Great shoe inserts but not insoles. They relieve Plantar fasciitis and foot pain, and there’s enough support, but don’t expect the comfort level of insoles.
These can be used alone, but you can buy cheap insoles. Rather, they are orthotics, but they are great.
Pros:
- Durable
- Extremely supportive
- It can be used with Sperry Insoles
- Better replacement for Sperry Insoles
- Takes less space
Cons:
- Not the most comfortable
- Fairly expensive
Powerstep Pinnacle Maxx Insoles
This is an upgraded version of the earlier mentioned Powerstep Pinnacle insoles.
According to the Amazon description, they are unis*x and should correct over-pronation and provide maximum support to your arch. This product is rated over 4 stars with 13,000 contributions. Let’s see what the reviews have to say;
These are more comfortable than I expected. I ordered some shoes, but they arrived late. While waiting for my shoes, I decided to get these insoles.
Those shoes were expensive and supportive. I didn’t think these Insoles could give as much support. They blew my mind. I will put these in my other shoes instead of wasting money on expensive ones.
I work with these insoles in my shoes for 12 straight hours every day. The Powerstep insoles are very comfortable for daily wear, very supportive, and relieve pains in the feet.
Pros:
- Very comfortable
- Better arch support
- Corrects over-pronation
- Relieves Plantar fasciitis
- Medically recommended
- Better replacement for Sperry Insoles
- Thick
Cons:
- Fairly expensive
- Not so soft
- Takes up space
Dr. Scholl Running Insoles
This is another pair of Insoles from Dr. Scholl. You know how supportive running shoes should be.
This is one way to turn your casual shoes into running shoes or just get that comforting support of running shoes.
According to the product description, a pair of Dr. Scholl Running Insoles should absorb shock, relieve Plantar fasciitis and Shin Splints, and prevent some running injuries.
Below are the top reviews that mention Dr. Scholl’s Running Insoles;
I run about 100 miles every month and two months ago, I developed a painful shin splint for the first time.
It became extremely hard to run 2 miles at a time. Sometimes, I couldn’t even sleep due to the aches. I took a break for two weeks, but that didn’t stop the pains.
I realized a slight and barely noticeable change in my posture. I decided to try these insoles, hoping they would correct my posture.
I don’t know how but it worked. It felt unusual at first but I felt it working on my affected foot. I thought there was no way to run in them, due to how they initially felt.
I tried running and now I’m used to them. The shin splint has reduced by 75% and it’s depleting slowly. I recommend these.
I was having horrible pains in my ankles and shins, after getting a new pair of running shoes. These inserts worked perfectly well. I am hopeful that they would be durable as well.
Pros:
- Relieves foot pain
- Eases shin splints
- Comfortable
- Corrects posture
- Better replacement for Sperry Insoles
- Fairly Affordable
- Provides support
Cons:
- More Support in the heel area
- Not the most durable
Dr. Feet Adjustable Inserts
This is another Doctor on the list. A pair of orthopedic insoles should be in your shoes for the utmost support and relief for the pains in your feet. Below are top reviews that mention Dr. Feet Adjustable Inserts;
It’s amazing. They are small, but they work beyond expectations. I used moleskin to prevent blisters. These little inserts do it so easily. These are so comfortable. They work like magic.
It works perfectly well and fixes my problem, but they slide around in my shoes.
Pros:
- Very comfortable
- Very cheap
- Supportive
- Relieves foot pain
- Prevents blisters
- It doesn’t take up space
- Better replacement for Sperry Insoles
- Sticks to the bottom of shoes
Cons:
- Thin
- Low cushioning
Timberland Pro Anti-fatigue Insoles
These Insoles may be the most supportive and thick pair of insoles on this list. This is not the type that sacrifices comfort for quality.
You can slip these in virtually any pair of shoes for perfect support. It is recommended for work boots. The “anti-fatigue” in the description is not just there.
These Insoles provide enough support to slow down stress. Check out the top reviews that mention Timberland Pro Anti-fatigue Insoles;
These are great for all-day support. I tend to wear out my insoles and shoes, due to the nature of my work. I have owned many pairs but these lasted the longest. They are thick and well-cushioned.
I bought these insoles for my Timberland sneaker boots for a tour. The tour lasted two weeks and I had the boots on, all through. My feet never hurt. They got even more comfortable as I wore them.
Pros:
- Fairly durable
- Very comfortable
- Thick
- Well-cushioned
- Very supportive
- Delays stress
- Better replacement for Sperry Insoles
Cons:
- Runs slightly large
- Fairly expensive
Spenco Polysorb Heavy-duty Insoles
You can tell that these insoles are built to get you on your feet for as long as you wish.
It has a product rating of 4.5 stars on Amazon, with over 8,000 contributions. Below are the top reviews that mention Spenco Polysorb Heavy-duty Insoles;
I suffer from rheumatoid arthritis and I find it hard to walk. That was till I started using Spenco soles.
When I have these in my shoes, I can stand and walk without pain in my feet. It’s been almost 10 years now and they still look pretty new. I recommend these to anyone else with rheumatoid arthritis.
These are the best shoe inserts I’ve used. I got this for a Washington trip; 20,000 steps per day. These insoles didn’t just survive.
They make my feet feel brand new. Plantar Fasciitis and other foot pains are gone. I’m extremely impressed.
Pros:
- Most durable
- Comfortable
- Relieves Plantar Fasciitis
- Eases foot pain
- Arch support
- Better replacement for Sperry Insoles
Cons:
- Fairly expensive
Conclusion
There are many reasons for you to replace the insoles in your Sperry shoes right now. First, you can wear the shoes without the Sperry insoles and might not feel a difference.
That is the biggest reason you must feel real comfort for the first time. With the insoles listed above, you have the maximum level of support, shock absorption, cushioning, and even pain relief.
Instead of waiting for your Sperry insoles to get ruined, toss them out and get comfortable.
Related: